Welcome to Town Hall Deli
Nestled in South Orange, NJ, Town Hall Deli proudly claims the title of the birthplace of the iconic Sloppy Joe. Established with a commitment to quality, this beloved deli serves up classic American fare, renowned for its expertly crafted sandwiches and homemade soups. Notably, the Sloppy Joe features a delightful blend of turkey, roast beef, Swiss cheese, and house-made coleslaw on freshly baked rye, leaving patrons in awe. Patrons rave about the attentive service, inviting ambiance, and a broad selection of delectable side dishes. Town Hall Deli is not just a meal; it’s a culinary experience worth sharing and returning for.
-
74 1st St, South Orange Village, NJ 07079 Hotline: (973) 762-4900
Welcome to Town Hall Deli, a cherished culinary landmark located in the charming South Orange Village, NJ. This deli, nestled at 74 1st St, is famed not just for its sandwiches but for revolutionizing what we know as the Sloppy Joe—a dish that has garnered almost mythical status among sandwich enthusiasts. With a phone number to call for inquiries at (973) 762-4900, you’re just a call away from planning your visit to this iconic eatery.
The menu at Town Hall Deli is a delightful homage to classic deli fare, prominently featuring their signature Sloppy Joe, an elegantly assembled concoction of turkey, roast beef, Swiss cheese, crispy coleslaw, and Russian dressing, all nestled in a firm crusty rye bread. Reviewers are quick to highlight the unique flavor balance and fresh ingredients—a testament to the deli's commitment to quality. In fact, customer Gary F. raves, "The original Sloppy Joe... High-quality meats and proper rye bread." It’s a testament to the craftsmanship that goes into each sandwich, making it a feast for both the eyes and the palate.
- Sandwich Suggestions: Town Hall’s menu has something for everyone. Some standout offerings include the Town Hall Roasted Turkey Sandwich, Brisket Sandwich, and Prosciutto Sandwich, all priced around $18.39. For those wishing to venture beyond the basics, the Chicken Salad Special combines bacon, lettuce, and melted Swiss for an indulgent treat.
- Soups: Pair your deli delight with a creamy Cream of Turkey or Cream of Mushroom Soup, both priced at only $8.00.
Dining at Town Hall Deli is not just about the food; it’s an experience. As Ron P. eloquently noted, "The ambience is classic deli, plenty of seats inside and outside." The service is attentive, and the comfort of enjoying a fantastic meal in a homey setting keeps patrons returning for more. Notably, the assembly line style prep draws you into the preparation process—a culinary theatre where you can appreciate the meticulous care that goes into each order.
For those looking to grab something to go, the deli also offers a variety of side dishes, take-home foods, and snacks, making it a convenient stop for a hearty lunch or a quick dinner. The local charm and warm authenticity encapsulated in Town Hall Deli make every meal feel like a return to comfort food roots.
So whether you’re a long-time patron or a curious first-timer, Town Hall Deli promises a delicious experience that transcends just a meal—it's a bite into history. Like many before you, you might just find yourself falling in love with their Sloppy Joe, often described as “the sloppy Joe of my dreams.” Come and savor the delights at Town Hall Deli; it’s a journey worth taking in the world of sandwiches.
The original Sloppy Joe The iChi in type High quality meats. Proper rye bread. Good soups and traditional desserts
Finally had the sloppy joe here (twice) after years of reading about this place. A really great sandwich! The balance of ingredients is just perfect.
Great deli with a lot of food options. Known for their sloppy joe. They are a little slow today but given it holiday party time it's understandable. Average sandwich price $12-20 but well worth it.
Sandwiches were Great, Sloppy Joe is a unique delicious sandwich.Service was attentive. Ambience,classic deli, plenty of seats inside and outside. I got a small sloppy Joe yesterday was delicious. I'm going back again today to try something different. .
Their sloppy joe consisting of turkey and roast beef is amazing. Their construction of all sandwiches is uniquely precise and delicious, very easy to consume. It has a great assortment of side dishes, take home foods, drinks, candy, chips. It's kind of historic. Worth going to. Two people can split one sandwich.
This is the sloppy Joe of my dreams. It's got all the parts. The special rye bread, baked especially for them is a sliver of pleasure. A firm crust that frames the tangle of excellent coleslaw stays intact through each savory bite. The corned beef is exceptionally tender with just the right texture. The turkey is fresh roasted. And the thousand island dressing smooth and robust. A slab of Swiss keeps this sandwich authentic. It's a nice sandwich. A nice sandwich. A Dr. Brown's Root Beer washes this whole memory into your belly. You could share the half order. It's more than you'd expect.
First off, I have no idea why the reviews for The Town Hall are 3.5 Stars. They do a fantastic job and there's no other sandwich place around like them. I do however have a small negative review after ordering a sloppy joe from goldbelly. It came beautifully made as always, but it was quite dry, even though I asked for extra Russian dressing. I recommend them to include extra Russian dressing on the side to protect from this happening. If I just add my own Russian dressing, it's not going to taste the same. It also would have been nice if they included a couple of pickles which you would get if you ordered one when you were there. In this case I ordered two sloppy joes and I was expecting at least a couple of pickles. Other than that, the sandwiches were excellent, and I'll try to make my own Russian dressing tomorrow similar to theirs. I will actually call them to ask what I should add. With all this said and some negative comments, I still give them five stars!
#AfterWeLawyerWeEat! Ventured to the storied Town Hall Deli in South Orange, NJ after Court which is heralded as the Birthplace of the Sloppy Joe. #FirstTimerAlert. Classic joints like this, walk in, pronounce my first timer status, and tell them to "set me up." They sure did. The whole Sloppy Joe with Turkey, Roast Beef, Swiss, Dry Cole Slaw, and Russian Dressing on Rye. Half Sour Pickles. Boylan's Orange Soda. And their light and fluffy Cheesecake. Wow. What a meal. Check it out if you haven't already! #MajorLeagueGrubbin #NomNomNom
Awesome! A++ Highly recommend! Love this place. Order to FL and use them for gifts. Will for sure be back.
Medium sized venue with metered street parking on an uphill one way street. It's also near a paid parking garage. We have been coming here for YEARS & I've never reviewed it. We love this place, they have the best Sloppy Joe's hands down. They are known for them & you'll understand why if you try it. Assembly line style prep that you can watch, typical deli setup, drinks & chips. Worth a stop every time! Grades: Ham & Cheese Joe: A+ Favorite Joe: A+